Tag: early retirement

One More Year Syndrome: The Hidden Trap Keeping You from Retirement

If you’ve been researching retirement lately, you’ve probably encountered content about something called “one more year syndrome.” This concept has been gaining traction across YouTube channels, podcasts, and financial forums, but what exactly is it, and why should you care?

One more year syndrome describes the tendency for pre-retirees to continuously postpone their retirement by convincing themselves they need to work “just one more year.” Sound familiar? You’re not alone. This pattern affects countless people who are financially ready to retire but keep finding reasons to delay.

What Is One More Year Syndrome?

One more year syndrome occurs when you give yourself excuses to work another year, even though you have the financial capacity to retire. These excuses might sound like:

  • “I need to add more money to my portfolio.”
  • “The market valuations look scary right now.”
  • “Inflation is making me nervous.”
  • “There are tariffs looming on the horizon.”
  • “Healthcare costs before Medicare eligibility worry me.”
  • “I don’t know what I’ll do with my time in retirement.”

The truth is, there’s always something uncertain on the horizon. Think about any time you’ve challenged yourself to try something new – that feeling of unease before stepping into uncharted territory is completely natural. Just like a child reciting a poem in front of their peers feels terrified for weeks beforehand, but once they’re doing it, they realize it wasn’t so scary after all.

For many pre-retirees, you’ve spent your career being the go-to person. You’re the problem solver, the one putting out fires, the person others turn to for advice and help. You have meaning, purpose, and respect in your field and community. The idea of leaving that behind for an uncertain next chapter can feel genuinely frightening.

Understanding the Content Creator’s Angle in Retirement Planning

Here’s something important you need to understand: many people creating content about one more year syndrome are retirement planners and financial advisors. They want people to retire, or at least seriously consider retiring soon, because that creates business opportunities for them.  This is coming from a fellow content creator and retirement planner!  (At least I’m upfront about it).

This doesn’t mean their advice is wrong, but you need to understand the incentive structure. When you see content saying, “don’t work another year, you’re wasting your time, stop slaving away for the man,” ask yourself who is packaging that message and what their angle might be.

Every content creator has an angle. The key is being aware of where the content is coming from so you can evaluate it appropriately. This awareness doesn’t invalidate the message – it might still be exactly what you need to hear – but it helps you consume it more thoughtfully.

Why Mortality Makes Us Rethink When to Retire

Sometimes life provides wake-up calls that force us to reconsider our retirement timing. Recently, a podcast listener reached out to see if he could retire earlier than he had planned.  The reason?  He lost 3 of his close friends over the last year. That kind of mortality reminder hits differently than abstract retirement planning discussions.

I remember back in my TIAA days, I worked with a sweet math professor looking for help with retirement planning.  She planned to work until 65 to become eligible for Medicare, and she was incredibly excited about traveling the world. For three years, her excitement built with each planning meeting. Then, unexpectedly, she passed away at 64 – just months before her planned retirement.

These stories aren’t meant to create fear, but they highlight an important reality: time isn’t guaranteed. When you see people around you pass away, get sick, or become frail, it naturally makes you reevaluate what you’re doing today. This response is completely normal and healthy.

Three Questions to Evaluate Your Retirement Readiness

To address one more year syndrome effectively, ask yourself these three critical questions:

Question 1: The Financial Standstill Test

Assuming nothing changed financially over the next year – even if the markets didn’t cooperate and your portfolio balance stayed exactly the same 12 months from now – would you still work that one more year?

What if you had a crystal ball showing your net worth wouldn’t change despite working another year, would you still choose to work? If the only reason you’re working is to add more money to your portfolio, even though you already have the capacity to retire today, you might be suffering from one more year syndrome.

Question 2: The Money-No-Object Test

If money weren’t an issue and you didn’t need to add more to your portfolio, would you still be doing what you’re doing today?

Remember, retirement doesn’t have to mean sitting in a rocking chair sipping drinks all day. Maybe you’d work occasionally as a consultant, volunteer, travel, or start a nonprofit. But the question is: if you didn’t need your job financially, would you still choose to spend most of your day and week doing that job?

If the answer is yes, and you can still pursue other important activities and relationships, then keep working. But remember – nothing is guaranteed.

Question 3: The Five-Year Horizon Test

If you were told today that you had five more good, healthy “go-go” years left, would you still work that one more year?

How would this knowledge change your decision about working another year?

Finding Purpose Beyond Traditional Retirement

The concern about losing purpose in retirement is valid and important. In 1 Peter 4:10, it says, “Each one should use whatever gift he has received to serve others, faithfully administering God’s grace in its various forms.”

This doesn’t suggest that retirement is bad; rather, it asks whether you’re using your gifts to serve others. If work is preventing you from doing that, maybe you should consider retiring sooner than planned. However, if you have no purpose planned for retirement, you’re likely to feel lost.

Retirees who feel lost don’t feel good, and people who don’t feel good aren’t enjoyable to be around. You need purpose, meaning, fulfillment, and energy in retirement. But there are many ways to make an impact and put your time, talents, and treasures to work beyond traditional employment.

Making Your Decision About One More Year Syndrome

Here’s what to take away from this discussion:

First, when you encounter content about one more year syndrome, understand where it’s coming from. Consider who is delivering the message, how they’re packaging it, and what their angle might be. Everyone has motivations, and being aware of them helps you evaluate advice more effectively.

Second, recognize that despite potential biases, this message might still be exactly what you need to hear today. Time isn’t guaranteed, and you can’t predict how many good years you have remaining. This reality has played out countless times throughout retirement planning careers.

Third, use those three questions to guide your thinking. They might lead you to conclude that you should continue working – maybe for five more years instead of one. Or you might realize you hate what you’re doing and need to figure out a plan to transition now, even if it’s not full retirement.

If money isn’t the issue and you dislike your job, it’s probably time to reevaluate what you’re doing. There are plenty of ways to make an impact and use your skills meaningfully.

Moving Forward with Your Retirement Decision

One more year syndrome is real, and it affects many people who are actually ready to retire but keep finding reasons to delay. The key is honest self-reflection about your true motivations.

Are you working another year because you genuinely need the money, or because you’re afraid of the unknown? Do you love what you do and find meaning in it, or are you staying because it feels safe and familiar?

Your retirement planning should go beyond financial calculations to include questions of purpose, meaning, and how you want to spend your remaining healthy years. Whether you decide to retire now, work one more year, or continue for several more years, make sure that decision is based on thoughtful consideration rather than fear or habit.

The goal isn’t to minimize your retirement years but to maximize the meaningful use of whatever time you have left. Sometimes that means working longer, and sometimes it means taking the leap into retirement sooner than you initially planned.

At Imagine Financial Security, we help individuals over 50 with at least a million dollars saved navigate these complex retirement decisions. If you are looking to

  • Maximize your retirement spending
  • Minimize your lifetime tax bill
  • Worry less about money

You can start by taking our Retirement Readiness Questionnaire on our website at www.imaginefinancialsecurity.com, so we can learn more about how we can help you on your journey to and through retirement.

Not quite ready to take the questionnaire, but want helpful tips and resources? Sign up for our monthly newsletter and/or subscribe to our YouTube channel. This is for general education purposes only and should not be considered as tax, legal, or investment advice.

Why You Should Plan for Early Retirement Even If You Don’t Plan to Retire Early

I recently met with two clients who completely changed how I think about retirement planning. Both were retiring much earlier than they had anticipated, and both situations were related to unexpected health issues. One client is now on disability, though thankfully, his wife is still working for a few more years, and he does have a disability policy in place. The other received a cancer diagnosis and is potentially retiring much earlier than planned as well.

These conversations took me back to my days studying for the RICP (Retirement Income Certified Professional) designation. There was a statistic that really resonated with me. After reviewing my coursework and notes, I found it: 51% of retirees retired earlier than anticipated. That’s right! There’s a better than 50% chance that whatever age you think you’re going to retire, you’re going to retire earlier.

The number one reason? Health issues. This reality made me realize something important. We need to stop planning for a “normal” retirement age in our assumptions, even if we end up working until 70 or 65.

The Reality of Uncontrollable Retirement Factors

Let me share another example. I’m working with a client right now who’s 62. He plans to work at least until 65, when he becomes eligible for Medicare. During the pandemic, he moved from New York to Florida. The plan was to work remotely, feel good, and coast into retirement while continuing to build his assets.

Unfortunately, the company is bringing everyone back to the office. He has two choices.

  1. Move back to New York
  2. Pick a random satellite location in Florida to work in

Neither of these is convenient based on where he now resides. So, he might retire this year.

My point is that things outside our control often lead people to retire earlier than planned. The inputs you give your financial advisor, including “I want to work until 70,” significantly impact the calculations on:

  • How much you need to save for retirement
  • How much risk you need to take
  • How long your portfolio needs to last while you’re spending it down

I don’t think it’s prudent to build those optimistic assumptions into your plan.

I recommend assuming you’ll retire at 62, 63, or 64, even if you love what you do, and genuinely want to work until 70. Then control what you can control.

Understanding Why People Retire Early

The research shows us exactly why 51% of people retire earlier than expected. Here’s the breakdown:

46% cited health reasons – This is the largest category and completely uncontrollable. Whether it’s a sudden diagnosis, chronic condition, or physical limitations, health issues force many people out of the workforce earlier than planned.

30% were laid off or offered an early retirement package – Again, this is largely uncontrollable. Company restructuring, economic downturns, or industry changes can force your hand regardless of your personal timeline.

11% needed to care for a loved one – Caring for aging parents, a sick spouse, or other family members is another uncontrollable factor that can derail retirement plans.

When you add these three categories together, that’s 87% of early retirees who left work due to circumstances beyond their control. This is why early retirement planning makes sense for everyone, not just those dreaming of early retirement.

What Changes When You Plan for Early Retirement

If you’re 55 and had been planning to work until 70, you probably had a pretty nice-looking financial plan. You’d get maximum Social Security benefits at 70, which would line up perfectly with when you start portfolio withdrawals, creating no income gap. But what happens when you plan to retire at 60 or 62 instead? Several things change, and you need to prepare for them.

1. You Need to Save More and Invest More

This one’s pretty straightforward. A good saver typically saves about 10-15% of their gross income. But if you’re planning for early retirement – even if you don’t actually retire early – I’d argue you need to save closer to 20-25% of your gross income.

I’m personally planning to have financial independence before I turn 55. Now, I love what I do and don’t see myself at 60 doing nothing. I’m having more fun in my career today than I ever have. But by planning for retirement significantly earlier, I’m building the option to quit if I want to or sell my business if I want to. That’s the power of early retirement planning – it gives you choices.

2. Healthcare Before Medicare

Medicare eligibility starts at 65, and many people work until then specifically because they’re afraid of what they’ll do for health insurance if they retire at 60, 61, or 62. But here’s what most people don’t realize: buying private health insurance or through the Affordable Care Act isn’t that complicated.

I do it with my family. It’s not cheap, but if you’re retired, your taxable income is going to be pretty low. You might have some interest income from bonds or high-yield savings accounts, maybe dividends from stocks or ETFs, perhaps Social Security or a pension. But generally, folks who retire at 60-62 have relatively low taxable income.

This low income often qualifies you for ACA subsidies. If your income is relatively low, your health insurance costs could be next to nothing – possibly less expensive than what you were paying when you were working. Don’t let healthcare force you into a job you hate until 65 just because everyone else talks about working until Medicare kicks in.

3. Stay Aggressive with Your Investment Strategy Longer

This is a mistake I see repeatedly. People preparing for retirement think, “I need this money in one, two, three, or four years, so I need to dial back my risk.” Or worse, they pick a target-date fund for 2025 because they want to retire in 2025, and these funds force you into being super conservative.

By doing this, you’re bringing inflation and longevity risk into the picture more than necessary. When I say stay aggressive, I’m not talking about putting 100% in stocks or betting everything on high-risk investments. I’m talking about maintaining a higher equity allocation than traditional retirement advice suggests.

If the benchmark portfolio for retirees is 60% equities and 40% fixed income, maybe you stay at 75% or 80% equities for the first phase of retirement. This helps you capture returns early on (assuming the market cooperates), continue building your portfolio, and protect against inflation and longevity risks that come with retiring earlier.

4. Plan for Longevity

If you retire at 60 and have longevity in your genes or excellent health, there’s a possibility you or your spouse may live 30-35 years in retirement. This goes hand in hand with staying aggressive longer – you may need to maintain a fairly aggressive investment approach throughout your retirement years to protect against inflation and longevity risks.

You also need a sound Social Security strategy to maximize survivor benefits should one spouse pass away before the other. That Social Security benefit will be one of the best inflation hedges in your retirement income plan, so you’d better maximize it if you plan to live a long life.

5. Develop a Sound Income Distribution Plan

If you plan to delay Social Security until 70 to get maximum benefits but retire at 60, that’s a potential 10-year gap where you’ll have no Social Security income. You need to replace that income with portfolio withdrawals and distributions.

Preparing your portfolio for income distributions is critical. You need a disciplined, unemotional, repeatable process to generate cash flow monthly or quarterly. We’ve all heard about buying low and selling high. When you’re accumulating wealth and saving in your 401(k) or IRA, it’s all buying – you’re purchasing shares of investments.

But in the distribution phase, you’re not just buying anymore. You’re turning the portfolio on for income. Some will come from cash flows such as interest and dividends, but others will come from selling investments each month, quarter, or year. Having a disciplined process so you’re not selling the wrong thing at the wrong time is critical for maintaining portfolio longevity when retiring early.

What Happens If You Plan Early But Don’t Retire Early?

Let’s say you do all these things and prepare to retire early, but you don’t actually retire early. What’s the impact? Nothing really negative that I can think of.

The main drawback is that you might need to tighten your belt more. If you’re struggling to save 10-15% and early retirement planning calls for 20-25%, that might be tough without working a second job or getting a significant pay raise. But if you have the capacity to save and invest more, there are only benefits.

You could potentially spend or gift more in retirement. Maybe you could build your dream home or have a vacation home free and clear. You might have better opportunities to leave a financial legacy for your children and grandchildren. You could have different risk capacity – maybe you’ve saved more than enough for retirement, which allows you to take on more investment risk to build an even larger legacy for the next generation or for charitable goals.

Maybe this also allows you to set aside funds for self-funding long-term care. Long-term care risk is one of the top risks for any retiree today – those healthcare costs at the end of life and the potential burden on loved ones. If you’ve saved more than you need for your own retirement, you can potentially self-fund long-term care.

The Benefits of Early Retirement Planning for Everyone

The beauty of early retirement planning is that it benefits everyone, regardless of when you actually retire. It’s about building financial security and creating options in your life.

When you follow early retirement planning principles, you’re essentially stress-testing your financial plan. Instead of assuming everything will go perfectly – that you’ll work until 70, stay healthy, never get laid off, and never need to care for family members – you’re planning for reality.

This approach gives you financial flexibility. If you do face unexpected health issues, job loss, or family caregiving responsibilities, you’ll have options. You won’t be forced into desperate financial decisions because you’ll have built a solid foundation.

Even if none of these challenges arise and you work until your planned retirement age, you’ll be in a much stronger financial position. You’ll have more saved, better investment strategies, and multiple backup plans. That’s not a bad problem to have.

Taking Control of What You Can Control

The key insight from all of this is focusing on what you can control versus what you can’t.

You can’t control whether you’ll have health issues, whether your company will downsize, or whether you’ll need to care for aging parents. But you can control your savings rate, your investment strategy, your distribution process, and your ability to manage risk before and during retirement.

Let’s control what we can and plan for the worst while hoping for the best. That’s what smart early retirement planning is really about – not necessarily retiring early, but being prepared for whatever life throws your way.

And if you want help planning for your retirement, we’d love to help you.  At Imagine Financial Security, we help individuals over 50 with at least a million dollars saved navigate these complex retirement decisions. If you are looking to

  • Maximize your retirement spending
  • Minimize your lifetime tax bill
  • Worry less about money

You can start by taking our Retirement Readiness Questionnaire on our website at www.imaginefinancialsecurity.com, so we can learn more about how we can help you on your journey to and through retirement.

Not quite ready to take the questionnaire, but want helpful tips and resources? Sign up for our monthly newsletter and/or subscribe to our YouTube channel.

This is for general education purposes only and should not be considered as tax, legal, or investment advice.